Circumstances alter cases.
This proverb means that the specific details and context of a situation can change how a general rule or principle should be applied. The situation can change and therefore, change the way one looks at something or how something should be handled. It implies that people should consider the current situation and adapt their behavior or approach accordingly. It emphasizes the need for flexibility and judgment when making decisions, acknowledging that a one-size-fits-all approach may not always be appropriate. The general approach to something can change based on specific circumstances.
There is little information on the etymology of this phrase, apart from the fact that it was first recorded sometime in the 17th century.
This proverb is often applied to situations in which one’s circumstances are extenuating. The sample conversation below, which takes place between a university student and her financial advisor, illustrates the correct use of this proverb.
Matilda: I can’t award you this scholarship because you don’t meet the qualifications.
Brianna: If I don’t get this scholarship, I’ll have to drop out of college.
Matilda: I suppose I can try to persuade the scholarship committee to consider you. After all, circumstances alter cases.
This proverb underscores the importance of considering context, as well as the need for flexibility and judgment in applying rules and principles. It is a reminder that rules are not always absolute and that exceptions can be necessary when dealing with the complexities of real-life situations.
