APAD: Playing devil's advocate

"Playing devil's advocate" means to argue or present the opinions of the opposite side even though the person doesn't agree with the opinion they are presenting. In order for someone to be playing devil's advocate, they must be arguing or presenting a position that is the opposite of what they actually believe.

The purpose is to highlight what the opposing side feels and hopefully give another person some insight into why there is an opposition and how that opposition might react. Playing Devil's advocate is most commonly used when helping to make a decision.

It's very important to understand the difference between arguing an opinion and playing devil's advocate. If a person genuinely disagrees with an opinion and argues the opposite, they are not playing devil's advocate. They are stating their opinion. It is only a devil's advocate when the person is arguing or presenting an opinion that is the opposite of what they believe.

Playing devil's advocate can be a very helpful thing when done for the right reasons. By presenting and arguing a counter opinion, it can help people to see a different perspective and educate them on how other people think. It can be very helpful in preparing for a debate, understanding a sales market, or getting someone prepared to make a decision.

Historic background:
At one time the Roman Catholic Church had an official position that was termed the devil's advocate. The job entailed finding and presenting negative information on a person who passed away and was being considered for canonization. The idea was to present all the positive things the person did with negative as well.

-  https://study.com/learn/lesson/devils-advocate.html# with editing
--------------------------------------

Growing up with 稻香村 cookies, I always love eating them. For the past three years, Wlamart here has been selling them around Mid-Autumn Festival and Chinese New Year, and I bought close to 20 boxes (牛舌饼,桃酥) last year alone.

But for whatever reason, they are missing this year.  Instead, the store is selling some fancy looking mooncakes. I bought one box last week (pic #1), only to find that the white portion around the egg yolk ain't egg white, but lard fat (pic #2)! 怒

Hubby has a sweet tooth, so he played devil's advocate and asked me not to throw the mooncakes away before trying.

So I tried some after taking the fat out (pic #3), and found it's still too rich for my taste. 恨

I'm sure 白云 can make much better mooncakes, maybe even with some tomatoes. 加油

Cheers!

#1

#2

#3

所有跟帖: 

One should be able to buy devil's advocates just as they do -7grizzly- 给 7grizzly 发送悄悄话 7grizzly 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 08:51:20

indulgences and annulments. -7grizzly- 给 7grizzly 发送悄悄话 7grizzly 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 08:51:42

haha, maybe 1 can ;-) But, there're something can never be -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 09:12:19

bought, such as TRUE love and friendship! -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 09:13:49

Thanks! 中文是扮演魔鬼的辩护人,故意唱反调。 -硅谷居士- 给 硅谷居士 发送悄悄话 硅谷居士 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 09:38:48

+ 1!sometime some people like 2debate 4 the sake of debate~~ -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:00:15

Still digesting this 1. But found this in The Atlantic:)Tks! -暖冬cool夏- 给 暖冬cool夏 发送悄悄话 暖冬cool夏 的博客首页 (82 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:02:58

Hahahaha, secret of life no more:-)) Pls be back & share -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:05:19

your thoughts of today’s APAD whenever U have them.Thx! -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:07:04

That's all what democracy about, isn't it? -移花接木- 给 移花接木 发送悄悄话 移花接木 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:15:41

有人说东必有人说西,否则显得不民主。有卧龙必有凤雏 -移花接木- 给 移花接木 发送悄悄话 移花接木 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:17:13

Yes & No, I think;-) IMHO:民主==支持百花齐放。但支持不同观点者的言论自由 !=支持不同观点 -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:35:25

对秋后算账印象更深刻。 -7grizzly- 给 7grizzly 发送悄悄话 7grizzly 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:42:50

Yes, and those painful memories ... ... -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:44:29

eg."I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:45:50

death your right to say It" - Evelyn Beatrice Hall -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 10:47:01

2 b honest, I respect different opinions, but won’t go the -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 13:26:01

death ;-)) -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 13:26:51

A layer of lard fat!I suggest throwing them away. -天边一片白云- 给 天边一片白云 发送悄悄话 天边一片白云 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 12:44:17

I remember you make nice mooncake. -天边一片白云- 给 天边一片白云 发送悄悄话 天边一片白云 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 12:45:12

I will not make mooncake this year since children are away . -天边一片白云- 给 天边一片白云 发送悄悄话 天边一片白云 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 12:49:18

Yes, I did make them a few years ago, lots of work. :-( -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 13:18:31

Yes Ma’am:-)) Thx MM! Added: they in garbage bin now :-) -最西边的岛上- 给 最西边的岛上 发送悄悄话 最西边的岛上 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 09/18/2025 postreply 13:20:03

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!