从健康考虑,食用野生(wild caught)还是养殖(farm raised)鱼类?

有一点,养殖鱼类,为了鱼成长迅速、收成好,可能会采用改变鱼类性别的方式(sex reversal)。比如这个问题:

“Are there health concerns regarding to sex reversal in farming tilapia ?”

这是ChatGPT的回答:

Yes, there are some health and environmental concerns related to the practice of sex reversal in farming tilapia. Sex reversal is commonly used in tilapia aquaculture to produce all-male populations, which grow faster and more uniformly than mixed-sex populations. This is typically done by administering hormones, usually testosterone or 17α-methyltestosterone (MT), to the fry (young fish) during their early development stages.

Here are some of the concerns:

1. Human Health Concerns:

  • Hormone Residues: If the hormone treatment is not properly managed or if withdrawal periods before harvesting are not observed, there is a risk of hormone residues remaining in the fish flesh, which could pose health risks to consumers. However, studies have generally found that when managed correctly, hormone levels in the final product are minimal and considered safe.
  • Antibiotic Resistance: In some cases, hormone treatments may be combined with antibiotics to prevent disease, leading to concerns about antibiotic residues and the development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, which can pose a significant public health risk.

2. Environmental Concerns:

  • Hormone Pollution: The discharge of water containing hormones from aquaculture facilities into natural water bodies can potentially disrupt the endocrine systems of wild fish and other aquatic organisms, leading to reproductive and developmental issues.
  • Genetic Impact on Wild Populations: Escaped tilapia, especially those with altered sex ratios, could breed with wild populations, potentially disrupting local ecosystems and reducing genetic diversity.

3. Animal Welfare Concerns:

  • Stress and Mortality: The process of sex reversal can be stressful for the fish, and improper administration of hormones can lead to increased mortality rates during the early stages of life.

4. Regulatory and Ethical Concerns:

  • Regulatory Gaps: In some regions, the regulation of hormone use in aquaculture might be insufficient, leading to inconsistent practices and potential risks.
  • Ethical Concerns: The manipulation of sex in animals for commercial purposes raises ethical questions about the treatment of animals and the potential long-term impacts on species.

Overall, while sex reversal in tilapia farming can be effectively managed to minimize risks, it is important for aquaculture operations to follow best practices and adhere to regulations to ensure the safety of both consumers and the environment.

所有跟帖: 

实际上一周吃不了多少。除非顿顿吃,那点毒问题不大吧。 -lucky_rain- 给 lucky_rain 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 08:35:52

这是激素问题吧?不知道其它鱼类养殖有没有类似问题? -6degrees- 给 6degrees 发送悄悄话 (69 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 08:41:41

能吃野生的为啥吃养殖的?你看看越南的养虾视频就明白啦。就怕野生的也是圈养 挪威三文鱼就是 -MayX- 给 MayX 发送悄悄话 MayX 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 09:34:19

我是尽量不买挪威三文鱼, -6degrees- 给 6degrees 发送悄悄话 (726 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 09:40:31

别逗了,挪威会用日本的三文鱼?负责任地告诉你,全世界就是挪威的三文鱼最安全了。 -sgbigsell- 给 sgbigsell 发送悄悄话 sgbigsell 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 08/16/2024 postreply 02:17:48

那野生鱼还海水污染,还含重金属呐,养殖鱼不会。各有利弊,啥事都没有绝对。 -pickshell- 给 pickshell 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 10:00:10

养殖的也会,就是海里围个网,同样的海水 -种西瓜- 给 种西瓜 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 14:59:38

野生鱼有寄生虫的概率比养殖的高无数倍 -ephd- 给 ephd 发送悄悄话 ephd 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 10:57:24

+100 -Sequoia_CA- 给 Sequoia_CA 发送悄悄话 Sequoia_CA 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 12:02:37

鱼类只要做熟了再吃,寄生虫的危害就没有了吧? -6degrees- 给 6degrees 发送悄悄话 (137 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 13:21:29

野生的Omega3高. 养殖的omega6 高. Omega3抗炎症,Omega6造成炎症 -Jolene22- 给 Jolene22 发送悄悄话 Jolene22 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 10:22:00

养殖的三文鱼是比较肥嫩。ChatGPT核实了你说的: -6degrees- 给 6degrees 发送悄悄话 (3651 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 10:34:09

好像多数蔬菜水果是抗炎症的. 是不是所有的呢? -幕鼓晨钟- 给 幕鼓晨钟 发送悄悄话 幕鼓晨钟 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 08/13/2024 postreply 10:42:07

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!