我现在无法用对方是否撒谎来上诉对方,只能question of the law.
整个情节是,有两个房客居住同一个公寓,女房客(Jiliian)说男房客(Jonathan)有多人居住,5天后没有任何通知就搬走了,然后编故事告我,然后她居然赢了。
法官判我输的根据是, 我违反了 RSA 540:13-d:
(a) The tenant proves by clear and convincing evidence of violations; and
(b) The landlord failed to correct the violations within 14 days of the receipt of such written notice or, in an emergency, as promptly as conditions require; and
(c) The violations were not caused by the tenant, a member of the tenant's family or other person on the premises with the tenant's consent; and (d)
我反驳的理由是:
My tenant sent me a text message on 6/13/2019, but she moved out on 6/18/2019 without any notice, which is only 5 days, much shorter than 14 days for me to make a correction. In fact, I called Jonathan on the second day(6/14) after I received her message, and had corrected the issue. There was no any more complaint from her afterward. Jonathan also said he got Jillian's consent before his friends stayed there briefly. So, according to (b) and (c) above, I didn't violate Section 540:13-d.
Even for (a) above, Jillian asked me to keep it between me and her in that text message, the message was proved to be lying too, because she said "several complaints from Management", but the Apartment Management says no any complaints at all.
法官判决书的数额也弄错了, 因为房客开始也写错了。
这种情况能赢吗?