儿子申请大学的短文--写的是他的一次真实经历

来源: paterman 2023-03-16 04:02:11 [] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读: 次 (46623 bytes)
回答: 这样是真的吗?paterman2023-02-06 13:48:57

 

儿子申请大学的短文--写的是他的一次真实经历

 
来源:  于 2023-03-15 09:21:27 [] [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读: 3294 次 (4761 bytes)
本文内容已被 [ el98012 ] 在 2023-03-15 09:25:13 编辑过。如有问题,请报告版主或论坛管理删除.

他提交前一天才给我和他姐姐看一下,我看过之后说咱要不要试试申请好一点的学校,他说forget about it。他用这个申请UW。他还申请了其它的几所, 都是本地的。我们这里除了UW没什么像样的学校。

他那次的即时“演讲”真的很精彩,把在场的几十个大人和高中生都逗得一直笑声不断,幽默且富有意义。(前)市长也给予了很高的评价。

我对短文提的意见是我们在最后是不是“vision" 要大一些,要不要加两句像争取给亚裔与其它社团增进交流和了解做贡献的文字。他只是嗯了一声,也不知他改没改。

写作对我本人是非常非常大的挑战,高中时我每次作文的那(连在)一起的两节课我都写不出一点东西,最后都是胡写一些交作业了事,平均分数不及格。觉得两个孩子似乎这方面比我强不少。

 

I was on trial. As I shuffled to the podium to talk the jury shot me vicious stares, waiting intently for my inevitable screw-up the moment I dare open my mouth. My dad was so furious his red face could turn ice directly to steam. The judge didn't even bother looking up, for he was already as certain as I was of my guilt. I stammered. My words trembled. I secretly wished I had fallen on my face literally instead of figuratively.

I was not being tried for assault nor theft, but for being horribly, horribly unprepared. You see, I was a part of a fresh new wave of interns introduced into Mayor Lee's internship program, excited about its promise of bringing more attention towards Asian American communities and culture. Of course, with an opportunity this promising I immediately proceeded to forget about the vital introductory presentation on “what does it mean to be American”. A question so broad and vague that it was obvious that it was asking – nay, demanding – for a deeply philosophical response about the complex cultural and social values we possess in relation to America. Or in other words, a deeply philosophical response that I did not have. As if things couldn't get even worse, the first eager intern to present was immediately shot down with so much flak (from Mayor Lee himself!) that he had to drag his lead filled body back to his seat. “It's all over,” I thought to myself. A person as shy and unprepared as me couldn't even amount to a fifth of what he had to say.

The presentations went by one by one, and after a dreadful 35 minutes and 12 seconds it was my turn. With the only other option at my disposal being ejecting out of my chair straight through the second story window, something awoke within me. Something I didn’t even know I had. To my disbelief, my conscious decided that if I was going to run out of the room crying in front of the 40 young adults in the room, I was going to at least utter three sentences before I did so. I had to try.

The first few words dropped out of my mouth like stones. People were already beginning to relax in their chairs, their preconceptions of me in their minds coming true. But I kept talking. I slogged through the swamps of missing words and awkward phrases. I tripped, crawled, and stumbled all throughout navigating the jungles of finding what to say next. I trekked up the Mount Everest of finding enough courage to crack a joke.

                That day I had fooled everyone (or, at the very least, myself) that I could make speeches. Regardless of how well my improvised, patchworked speech was received, all I knew that by the end of it is that I felt amazing for having my genuine opinions expressed. Sure, I could never shake off the slight guilt of foolishly forgetting to prepare for this important presentation, but it took this blunder to find my passion for speech. If it wasn’t for this stressful moment of my life, I would’ve never found the passionate, bold, and admittedly a little bit too proud self that was hiding under the layers of excessive caution and nervousness.

I love speaking now. Whether it's as nerve racking as public speaking or as calm as simply talking to a friend I always search for ways to string words together. Sure, statistically speaking the majority of my sentences will be awkward, my phrasing incorrect, and my jokes painfully unfunny. But I am still forever grateful for the day when, with my back against the wall and staring (figurative) death in the face, I found my voice.

 

所有跟帖: 

• 赞!至少递之前你还看到了。俺到现在还不知道娃写了啥? -Xitong999 给 Xitong999 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (2 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 09:48:00

• 不知道娃是啥心理? -Xitong999 给 Xitong999 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (7 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 09:52:00

• 写得很真实。但是想怎么impress别人? -ginger789 给 ginger789 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (18 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 10:25:38

• 写得很生动,非常好啊 -igototibet 给 igototibet 发送悄悄话 igototibet 的博客首页 (0 bytes) (3 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 10:40:52

 

 

 

_________________

谢谢楼下el98012分享的essay, 文章本身写得不错,但立意远远不够顶校级别。我斗胆试析一下

 
来源:  于 2023-03-15 19:05:40 [] [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读: 1926 次 (2693 bytes)

https://bbs.wenxuecity.com/znjy/6146197.html

这篇文章写的是怯场(stage fright), 是每个人在某个时候某个地方都会碰到的。没有人天生可以口若悬河。

作者写得比较细腻,文字也不错。刻划得很好。作者最后克服了怯场,并找到了自己的voice。读者能够感觉身临其境,有共鸣。

问题是,如上面所言,这种经历,多多少少人人都有过。那么作者的经历或体会有什么与众不同之处?很遗憾,文章没能反映出来。

那么顶校/名校其实是在找“与众不同的人”,能够stand out的人。文章没能体现出这样一个人。

所以这是一个立意高度的问题。立意如果有欠缺,文字写得最美,也很难把孩子的与众不同的特质刻划出来。

就像一把沙,拳头握起来,沙都会流掉。

怎么写得与众不同?可以有很多种写法。

Sure, 作者克服了怯场,那么然后呢

注意这个“然后呢”才是这篇文章应该有的主干,而不是怯场/克服怯场本身因为后者其实只应是这篇大学申请文章的一个引子而已。

不同人(根据自己不同经历)可以有不同的“然后呢”。比如:

- 有鉴于自己的个人经历, 在学校组织了speech club (think toastmaster), 与同龄人一起...

- 这次克服怯场的经历,让自己对public speech产生了巨大的兴趣。为此参加了debate team...

- 这次克服怯场的经历,让自己对public speech产生了巨大的兴趣。为此,收集并深研了几百篇历史上著名的speech, 并与同学一起创办了一个Newsletter

- 这次克服怯场的经历,让自己对public speech产生了巨大的兴趣。为此,专门组织同学一起上了Harvard (or any other school) Prof XXX 的网课,发动同学课后探讨,并把课上学到的用到了YYY活动中

...

 

Now, a more unique and interesting personality starts to emerge and catch AO's eyes.

大家有没看到leadership? 顺着这个方向,我也已经隐约有点看到了。嘻嘻

 

已有8位网友点赞!查看

 

 

所有跟帖: 

• 分析的很好, 重要的是由你自己的经历升华到能为周围人做什么,帮祝了同样问题的孩子共同进步了吗,这才是精华的部分 -momjr 给 momjr 发送悄悄话 (95 bytes) (74 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:11:29

• 对, 自己的经历才能写得深入动人. 而且这些想法/做法要付诸日常行动 -beachlver 给 beachlver 发送悄悄话 beachlver 的博客首页 (108 bytes) (60 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:17:21

• 赞! -wd6 给 wd6 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (3 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:17:02

• 不觉得可以这样随便拔高意境。写出自己真实的感受就可以。再说, leadership 也得做了才有得写,否则难道杜撰? -pingsong 给 pingsong 发送悄悄话 pingsong 的博客首页 (167 bytes) (37 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:18:35

• 我觉得楼主是说有leadership的孩子会做后续的事情,不是说杜撰 -wd6 给 wd6 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (5 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:20:57

• 哦。那我理解错了。 -pingsong 给 pingsong 发送悄悄话 pingsong 的博客首页 (0 bytes) (1 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:23:33

• 不是杜撰拔高自己,而是真的做进一步的活动并把感受和impact写进去,才有可能打动藤AO,这也是大多数孩子很难做到的 -momjr 给 momjr 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (9 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:24:22

• 同意这样的说法。确实 impact很重要。但我反对靠 essay 提升高度的说法,是先有了leadership 的事情, -pingsong 给 pingsong 发送悄悄话 pingsong 的博客首页 (117 bytes) (41 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:32:07

• 要真是这么写了,这个文章一下就俗了。 -Tinkle88 给 Tinkle88 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (8 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:30:05

• 如果学生写作水平一般,是可以这么写,来点高大上。如果能写就不要瞎指挥了,按楼主建议很可能落入俗套 -米汤 给 米汤 发送悄悄话 米汤 的博客首页 (0 bytes) (35 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:51:12

• 赞!这样的营养帖多多益善。 -quantnj 给 quantnj 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (2 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:30:45

• 很有道理。 这种“克服困难”文AO见过的太多了,早已经是cliche,写出彩很难 -POTPRC 给 POTPRC 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (5 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:31:49

• 的确写克服缺点困难的要小心。因为你在强调自己的缺点。必须有翻盘的强有力情节才行。然后要提升高度。给AO一个理由录取你 -randomness 给 randomness 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (4 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:41:16

• 关键是无趣,都是开篇遇到困难,结尾征服困难,毫无悬念,10秒钟就可以看完 -POTPRC 给 POTPRC 发送悄悄话 (199 bytes) (51 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 20:02:25

• 同意这个分析 -wzuo 给 wzuo 发送悄悄话 wzuo 的博客首页 (0 bytes) (4 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:32:50

• 这么写,太套路了 -tibuko 给 tibuko 发送悄悄话 tibuko 的博客首页 (0 bytes) (4 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 19:56:12

• 楼主的建议是写essay的书上推荐的一个典型写法,叫做a slice of life.是个稳妥的写法 -风景线2 给 风景线2 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (4 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 20:33:26

• 分析得挺好,但一定要有EC能呼应才可以。Personal statement 八股也可以, -EagerBeaver 给 EagerBeaver 发送悄悄话 (159 bytes) (46 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 20:39:22

• 谢谢分享 -阿拉拉 给 阿拉拉 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) (0 reads) 03/15/2023 postreply 21:12:00

• 这就是为什么我不喜欢文科。什么好什么不好没有统一标准。 -4657238 给 4657238 发送悄悄话 (242 bytes) (7 reads) 03/16/2023 postreply 03:17:43

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

所有跟帖: 

转发:沪风.示儿(图比较长,请慢慢往下滑).png 来源: long_short 于 2023-04-08 -paterman- 给 paterman 发送悄悄话 (6292 bytes) () 04/08/2023 postreply 17:46:17

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!

发现Adblock插件

如要继续浏览
请支持本站 请务必在本站关闭/移除任何Adblock

关闭Adblock后 请点击

请参考如何关闭Adblock/Adblock plus

安装Adblock plus用户请点击浏览器图标
选择“Disable on www.wenxuecity.com”

安装Adblock用户请点击图标
选择“don't run on pages on this domain”