Plz notice that I was ONLY talking ...

本帖于 2012-10-09 11:16:00 时间, 由普通用户 旖旎风光 编辑

about Suzuki method in piano learning.  I never doubt that Suzuki's success in single-note instruments learning, such as strings and harp (of course, harp plays chords occasionally).  However, with piano playing, reading is so much more demanding than any other instruments.  I have seen very few cases of true, long-term success.  If you compare the percentage of Suzuki piano teachers to that of teachers of other instruments, the former is way lower.  It tells you somthing.  And I know many teachers refuse to take Suzuki transfer students.  Well, Suzuki always try to use a few big names to convince people it works with piano learning as well, e.g. Andre Watts,, who "graduated" from Suzuki system.  There are always exceptions around.  You throw any methods at Mozart, he would become Mozart.  Believe or not, Chopin had never taken any piano lessons from any professional pianist.  Abby Simon does not read music, and he has been a world-class pianist for long time.  But, don’t forget one fact, mediocrity fits majority of us perfectly.   We only try to squeeze everything out of our limited resources.  Suzuki (piano method) is definitely not the best way to go.

所有跟帖: 

专家的意见是很不错的,不过这里大部分是玩票的,包括这位又爹又妈的孩子:))~~~~~~ -mysc1234- 给 mysc1234 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 10:26:20

Nothing to do with the topic, -Passerby- 给 Passerby 发送悄悄话 (561 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 11:39:20

用外接麦克风的话,AGC是可以关掉的,这个不是问题。 -mysc1234- 给 mysc1234 发送悄悄话 (338 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 12:14:52

Thanks. One thing I don't understand. -Passerby- 给 Passerby 发送悄悄话 (468 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 13:29:21

我也听说Suzuki方法学弦乐还不错,学钢琴则反对的人多 -walkabout- 给 walkabout 发送悄悄话 (224 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 10:34:01

Suzuki方法学适合低幼琴童,大娃还是 -又当爹来又当妈- 给 又当爹来又当妈 发送悄悄话 又当爹来又当妈 的博客首页 (145 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 10:42:23

U can't put those two side by side, they totally different. -Passerby- 给 Passerby 发送悄悄话 (1133 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 12:11:16

U can put those two one after another -又当爹来又当妈- 给 又当爹来又当妈 发送悄悄话 又当爹来又当妈 的博客首页 (425 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 13:07:02

呵呵,看是什么学院派老师了 -walkabout- 给 walkabout 发送悄悄话 (118 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 12:29:42

我觉得和乐器无关,只和年龄有关, -又当爹来又当妈- 给 又当爹来又当妈 发送悄悄话 又当爹来又当妈 的博客首页 (71 bytes) () 10/09/2012 postreply 10:46:24

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!