No accounting info yet. ChatGPT analysis below
____________
That’s a smart question — and you’re right to be cautious.
Let’s break this down clearly:
1?? Understanding the Business Situation
Your friend’s HVAC company:
-
Revenue: ≈ $1M annually (gross billing)
-
Work type: Commercial new construction (typically lower margin, high working-capital demand)
-
Payment terms: Net 30–45 days
-
Billing limitation: Can only bill completed work each month (percentage-of-completion)
-
Reality: Often 60–90 days cash cycle because GCs pay late or “pay-when-paid.”
This means his company is essentially fronting payroll, materials, and overhead for 1–3 months before being reimbursed — a classic working capital crunch problem, common in subcontracting.
2?? Why Cash Flow Is Tight
Even with profit on paper, cash can be negative because:
-
He must pay suppliers and workers weekly, but gets paid much later.
-
Retainage (5–10%) is often held until the end of a project.
-
If a GC or property owner delays, he’s stuck waiting — and can’t pressure them much without risking future work.
So, this isn’t necessarily mismanagement — it’s a structural issue of the industry.
3?? Typical Solutions
Here are the common and practical fixes before equity investment:
| Option | How it Helps | Risk/Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Line of credit (LOC) from bank | Smooths cash flow gaps | Needs collateral, good credit |
| Invoice factoring / A/R financing | Sells invoices for 1–3% fee | Costly if used heavily |
| Negotiate better payment terms with GCs | E.g., partial progress draws, earlier billing | Limited leverage |
| Deposit billing or mobilization fee | Upfront payment before job starts | Depends on contract |
| Project scheduling discipline | Avoid overlapping too many large jobs | Management challenge |
If his main issue is payment timing (not unprofitability), a revolving credit facility or factoring is usually the first move.
4?? Investing in His Company — Pros and Risks
Pros:
-
If the business is solid and margins are good (10–20%), solving cash flow could boost growth.
-
You might negotiate preferred returns or profit-sharing in exchange for short-term capital.
Risks:
-
Payment dependency: If a general contractor or owner goes bankrupt or delays indefinitely, your capital can get locked up.
-
Low transparency: Construction accounting is complex — progress billing, retainage, and change orders can hide the true cash position.
-
Thin margins: Many commercial HVAC firms run net profit of only 5–8%, so one bad job can erase a year’s profit.
-
Your investment may function more like a loan (to cover cash flow) than true equity — but with more risk and less control.
5?? If You’re Considering Investing
You can protect yourself by:
-
Demanding financial statements (cash flow, AR aging, job cost reports).
-
Clarifying use of funds — is it for growth or just survival?
-
Structuring the deal as:
-
Secured short-term loan (with collateral, e.g. equipment, A/R, personal guarantee),
-
or convertible note (loan that can turn into equity if business grows),
-
rather than direct equity.
-
-
Monitor Accounts Receivable aging: If most AR is >60 days, it’s a red flag.
6?? Quick Red Flags to Watch
-
He owes suppliers or payroll >30 days late.
-
GC payments consistently exceed 60 days.
-
He’s taking jobs with low bid margins just to “keep busy.”
-
No clear accounting of project-level profitability.
Summary Recommendation
If the business is fundamentally profitable but starved for working capital:
A secured short-term loan with clear repayment tied to receivable collection is safer than an equity investment.
If payments are chronically delayed or the company lacks accounting clarity:
Do not invest — high risk of losing capital due to cash mismanagement or contractor insolvency.
If you’d like, I can help you design a simple financial model (Excel or Python) showing his monthly cash flow and what happens if you lend or invest a given amount (say $100k).
Would you like that?
Perfect — here’s a realistic sample P&L and cash flow snapshot for a small commercial HVAC contractor doing about $1 million/year in new construction work.
Sample Annual P&L – Commercial HVAC Contractor ($1,000,000 revenue)
| Category | % of Revenue | Annual ($) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue (billed) | 100% | $1,000,000 | From multiple GC projects |
| Direct Costs (COGS) | |||
| – Materials (ducts, units, controls) | 35% | $350,000 | Paid within 30 days |
| – Direct labor (techs/installers) | 40% | $400,000 | Paid weekly |
| – Subcontractors, permits, rentals | 5% | $50,000 | Variable by job |
| → Gross Profit | 20% | $200,000 | Within normal range for new build |
| Operating Expenses (Overhead) | |||
| Office salaries (admin, PM) | 5% | $50,000 | Small staff |
| Vehicle & fuel | 3% | $30,000 | Service trucks, gas |
| Insurance & bonding | 2% | $20,000 | Required for commercial work |
| Rent, utilities, phones | 1% | $10,000 | Office + warehouse |
| Tools, training, uniforms | 1% | $10,000 | Ongoing expense |
| Accounting, software, legal | 1% | $10,000 | QuickBooks, etc. |
| → Total Overhead | 13% | $130,000 | |
| EBIT (Operating Profit) | 7% | $70,000 | “Paper profit” before tax |
| Taxes & misc. | 1–2% | $10,000–$20,000 | |
| → Net Profit After Tax | 5–6% | $50,000–$60,000 | If everything goes right |
Cash Flow Reality
Even with $60K profit on paper, cash flow can be negative most months due to:
-
Billing lag: Only can bill completed % each month.
-
Payment delay: GCs pay 45–75 days after billing.
-
Retainage: 5–10% withheld until project completion.
Example Cash Flow Cycle:
| Item | Timing | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Pay labor & materials | Weekly/monthly | Immediate cash out |
| Submit progress invoice | End of month | +0 days |
| GC approves pay app | +15–30 days | Delay |
| GC receives owner payment | +15–30 days | Delay |
| Contractor gets paid | 60–90 days after work done | Major lag |
So the company might need $150K–$200K in working capital to keep payroll and suppliers current while waiting for receivables.
Investment Insight
If you invest in such a business:
-
Your money is likely to be used as working capital (bridge financing for receivables).
-
The company is profitable but illiquid.
-
Your biggest risk is receivable non-payment or extreme delay by the GC or building owner — not lack of sales.
Safer Investment Structures
| Structure | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Short-term secured loan | You earn interest (10–15%), secured by A/R or equipment | Needs legal paperwork |
| Revolving line of credit (you as lender) | Flexibility, gets repaid as invoices are paid | Must monitor receivables closely |
| Equity investment (partner) | Profit upside | No control, cash risk, slow paybacks |
Would you like me to make a simple Excel model (you can adjust job size, payment terms, and your investment amount) so you can see month-by-month cash flow and repayment timing?
It can help you decide whether your money should be a loan or equity.
