Why high dividend stocks are toxic

If a company really makes too much money, let's say PE of 5, or very low price to cash flow ratio. What's the best way to protect shareholders interest, especially the majority holder's interest?

If I'm the majority holder, I would just use the excess cash to buy all the remaining shares and delist it. I don't want to share this enomous cashcow with anybody. Why didn't I do that? because it's not really what it looks on the surface.

The high dividend mostly comes from a dying business or high debt load. It's never sustainable to pay dividend with higher rate than that of a junk bond. 

If a business is indeed minting money, it will go private. If it doesn't, it has no more growth, it's a matter of time before it's ultimate downfall.

Investment is simple, you just can't have wishful thinking.

所有跟帖: 

It all depends, and you must do your own diligence before -薄利多收- 给 薄利多收 发送悄悄话 (169 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:14:37

在9块买了ET,8% dividend, 涨到过$21,最近回撤到16.7 -spinach2005- 给 spinach2005 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:21:11

握手。这些 midstream stock 前两年表现极好。EPD, MPLX -薄利多收- 给 薄利多收 发送悄悄话 (33 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:24:11

Dividend 股票在down turn时就显出价值了,让你能坚持活下去,有活钱抄底 -darkrifle- 给 darkrifle 发送悄悄话 darkrifle 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:22:35

那只能等升值了,和买出租房没有现金流一样 -恒妈- 给 恒妈 发送悄悄话 (120 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:35:14

理解错误,不一样。绝大多数优秀的公司,都没有太多现金流/分红 -未知- 给 未知 发送悄悄话 未知 的博客首页 (427 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:55:20

我老公也这么说,我还是无法理解,公司做的再好不分红和买家没什么关系 -恒妈- 给 恒妈 发送悄悄话 (147 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 14:02:44

这么理解吧! -未知- 给 未知 发送悄悄话 未知 的博客首页 (570 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 14:31:37

投资就是要分散投资,高成长,高红利,国债,Municipal 都得投。 它们各自的税率也要考虑。 -playForever- 给 playForever 发送悄悄话 playForever 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:51:33

这几天高成长股涨的多了,又开始忘乎所以。觉得比芭菲厉害了。 -playForever- 给 playForever 发送悄悄话 playForever 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 13:53:09

股票不是哲学问题,要谈就谈具体的股票 -丁丁在美洲- 给 丁丁在美洲 发送悄悄话 丁丁在美洲 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 14:27:02

呵呵,许多同学就是喜欢谈论哲学。忘记了具体股票。 -桃花源里人家- 给 桃花源里人家 发送悄悄话 桃花源里人家 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 14:47:47

不能一概而论,他们之间可以转换的. -ASINPA- 给 ASINPA 发送悄悄话 (257 bytes) () 05/02/2025 postreply 19:03:56

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!