From as early as 1935 science journalists were making humorous associations between the comic strip character Popeye, Iron and Spinach. In 1981 consultant haematologist T.J. Hamblin published a paper in the British Medical Journal (BMJ) entitled Fake which made the traditional humorous association between Popeye, Iron and Spinach and claimed (without any references to support the story) that a 19th century data error led to a tenfold exaggeration of the iron content of spinach - which was then perpetuated by generations of other scientists who blindly accepted the Victorian data as accurate.
第一个是错的
From as early as 1935 science journalists were making humorous associations between the comic strip character Popeye, Iron and Spinach. In 1981 consultant haematologist T.J. Hamblin published a paper in the British Medical Journal (BMJ) entitled Fake which made the traditional humorous association between Popeye, Iron and Spinach and claimed (without any references to support the story) that a 19th century data error led to a tenfold exaggeration of the iron content of spinach - which was then perpetuated by generations of other scientists who blindly accepted the Victorian data as accurate.
所有跟帖:
• 回复:我觉得你的资料是错的 -玉洁冰清- ♀ (78 bytes) () 05/21/2010 postreply 23:59:05
• 不知道你想说的是什么 -东土大糖- ♀ (189 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 00:20:56
• 我发现这个东土大塘特别喜欢较真,自以为是。 -树根子HHH- ♀ (44 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 14:10:48
• 我也发现了,一遇到这类话题她就较劲,总认为她得到的信息才是真理。 -wtpp- ♂ (0 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 15:00:43
• 较真不对吗?道听途说什么也不经过思考验证的人才自以为是 -东土大糖- ♀ (0 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 15:32:07
• 你要想较真也得有点学问不是?写出点你自己的论据来征服大家 -树根子HHH- ♀ (116 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 15:58:51
• 看不明白是你的问题 -东土大糖- ♀ (0 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 19:03:04
• 何况我第一个回帖只是指出了那个故事是虚构的 -东土大糖- ♀ (0 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 19:06:24
• 你要是认为指出错误避免误导群众也算“指手画脚”那我对你也无话可说 -东土大糖- ♀ (0 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 19:14:46
• 回复:误导群众的恰恰是你 -玉洁冰清- ♀ (60 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 22:11:37
• 谁当真了? -东土大糖- ♀ (0 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 22:47:12
• 你较真的精神是难能可贵的,你的问题是总怀疑别人的信息都是不经思考道听途说的。 -wtpp- ♂ (70 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 16:12:22
• 经过调查后发现不对的我才否定 -东土大糖- ♀ (0 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 19:12:03
• 回复:你难道不知道这个维基百科不是权威? -玉洁冰清- ♀ (114 bytes) () 05/22/2010 postreply 17:45:30