I have started this hot debate quit a while ago in Flickr Strobist group. A lot of gurus there participated in it. I learned a lot from it...
(http://www.flickr.com/groups/strobist/discuss/72157627560408405/?search=engineering)
I don't have enough art sense therefore I call myself craftman: parameters, flashes, gears, reverse-engineering, maybe I can get a good one too.
Not like those people with a lot of art inpiration, they can pick up any camera and just capture that moment or scene. or those who have great sense of painting, they can PS and produce great photos.
My conclusion is: Enjoy yourself and be yourself in the photography.
Ps: hello, everybody, new here.