Paper Tigers or Hidden Dragons?

本帖于 2013-12-17 08:00:01 时间, 由普通用户 4AsianAmerican 编辑

Years ago, an NY Magazine article, titled "Paper Tigers", by Korean American journalist Wesley Yang caught my attention.  His thought-provoking question was what happens to the Asian overachievers when the test taking ends?  Are they paper tigers if they are only brilliant test takers?  And where are these tigers or hidden dragons after college if they are real? 

Today, when we cheer for the equally overachieving, as well as equally deserving, individuals (e.g. ivie/s/m admits), the question is still as relevant as two years ago when Yang's article was first published. 

My question to you, as a parent, is what may have prevented some of these overachievers from being leaders, successful entrepreneurs, best selling authors, star professors, and prominent CEOs? Judging from the dearth of succuessful Asian Americans, what you think is the main reason? Culture (e.g. risk averse)? Glass ceiling? Persionality (e.g. extrovert vs. introvert)? Discrimination/Asian stereotype (e.g. quiet and hardworking)?  What do you think? 

Paper Tigers

 

What happens to all the Asian-American overachievers when the test-taking ends?

By Wesley Yang 

Published May 8, 2011

 

所有跟帖: 

任何种子,生存的环境很重要。还是那句话, 说你行你不行也行,反之亦然。和在中国的高分比比就知道了 -pacsqc- 给 pacsqc 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:01:23

Are you saying environment is what makes and breaks? -4AsianAmerican- 给 4AsianAmerican 发送悄悄话 (92 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:08:24

回复:Are you saying environment is what makes and breaks? -微软的年龄- 给 微软的年龄 发送悄悄话 (619 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:19:01

回复:回复:Are you saying environment is what makes and breaks? -4AsianAmerican- 给 4AsianAmerican 发送悄悄话 (10936 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:36:47

结论下的太早。华人大规模移民不过20 几年,而且人数暴涨不过 -soundofsilence- 给 soundofsilence 发送悄悄话 soundofsilence 的博客首页 (369 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:10:57

回复:结论下的太早。华人大规模移民不过20 几年,而且人数暴涨不过 -4AsianAmerican- 给 4AsianAmerican 发送悄悄话 (178 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:15:50

3代造就一个贵族。华裔一代有自己的局限,对孩子的选择也会有局限, -soundofsilence- 给 soundofsilence 发送悄悄话 soundofsilence 的博客首页 (132 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:19:29

我对我们下一代还是很乐观的!因为最终,hardwork, family value, education always win -微软的年龄- 给 微软的年龄 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:26:41

是的。 -soundofsilence- 给 soundofsilence 发送悄悄话 soundofsilence 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:30:28

Important values, however.... -4AsianAmerican- 给 4AsianAmerican 发送悄悄话 (190 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:40:39

嗯。我的孩子一个就是人文,另一个估计还是science. which is fine with me. -微软的年龄- 给 微软的年龄 发送悄悄话 (85 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:42:37

Good to let them pursue their own passion -4AsianAmerican- 给 4AsianAmerican 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:45:06

这是第一代理工背景的人太多的影响,以后也会弱化。其实很多到第二代就 -soundofsilence- 给 soundofsilence 发送悄悄话 soundofsilence 的博客首页 (28 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:47:30

是文化问题,不是基因问题。儒学文化下东亚裔强于自律学习已知的东西,弱于探索unknown -ViBravo- 给 ViBravo 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:31:48

还有,不敢take risk! -微软的年龄- 给 微软的年龄 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:35:51

这是从贫困中刚走出来的一代的共性,不只华裔。等孩子们不会为该不该吃剩饭 -soundofsilence- 给 soundofsilence 发送悄悄话 soundofsilence 的博客首页 (30 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:39:42

100% 同意。 -微软的年龄- 给 微软的年龄 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:48:40

是文化问题 - 儒学文化下东亚裔强于自律学习已知的东西,弱于探索unknown -4AsianAmerican- 给 4AsianAmerican 发送悄悄话 (102 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 08:42:25

thanks for sharing this.. -qiaomaidou6- 给 qiaomaidou6 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 12/17/2013 postreply 09:04:18

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!