帖一篇说耶鲁艺术史课要改版的文章。另外听说,AP艺术史学名画:毛主席去安源。巴黎圣母院不在单子上

来源: greenoasis 2020-01-27 19:50:36 [] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读: 次 (17777 bytes)
本文内容已被 [ greenoasis ] 在 2020-01-27 20:11:00 编辑过。如有问题,请报告版主或论坛管理删除.

不是玩笑,是真的。说这是全世界复制最多的一幅画。一共250样艺术品。这边多一个那边就少一个。另外艾未未在此列。学他的葵花籽。

美国也要文革就是了。

https://nypost.com/2020/01/27/barbarians-at-yale-pc-idiocy-kills-classic-art-history-class/

Barbarians at Yale: PC idiocy kills classic art-history class

 

The intro art-history course at Yale University is the envy of the world. The students who qualify for this costly privilege, some of whom go on to run the nation’s major art institutions, relish densely packed, richly presented lessons about the brilliant brushstrokes of Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo, Rembrandt and the like.

Or not. As department chair and course instructor Tim Barringer explained to The Yale Daily News recently, the course was “problematic,” ­because it put European art on a pedestal, at the expense of other artistic traditions “equally ­deserving of study.”

Thus, a band of hyper-educated Visigoths will soon demolish Yale’s storied course “Introduction to Art History: Renaissance to the Present.” In its place, the neo-barbarians will teach mini-courses fit for those confident in the correctness of their political views: “art and politics”; questions of “gender, class and race”; and the relationship of art to capitalism and climate change. Students will learn little of enduring value.

It is true that there are other artistic traditions deserving of attention, but these are already taught. Crucially, the history of art is the history of the Renaissance and its influence. Drawing on the achievements of Greco-Roman civilization, key parts of which the Islamic world preserved, the Renaissance blossomed in the city-states of Italy in the 15th and 16th centuries.

Enriched by the past, the Renaissance pushed the boundaries of what we know and what we could achieve. It changed the world. It gave birth to American art, which was dominated by Europeans who brought their cultures with them.

It’s also true that Leonardo da Vinci is guilty of being a Dead White Male, as are Michelangelo and the whole pantheon of Renaissance artists. The Renaissance was intertwined with the rise of modern banking, a time when power-hungry and wealthy patrons used art for self-glorification. It arose when explorers set sail for other worlds, ushering in colonialism. There was no #MeToo.

But all that is not a news flash. Countless scholarly essays have been devoted to laying bare the dark side of Western art. Still, the art puritans are unsatisfied. Like the Islamic State’s attacks on antiquities in Iraq and Syria, or the Christian iconoclasm of the Reformation, modern-day iconoclasts in Ivy League universities would tear down all that offends them for failing to conform to their liberal certainties.

You have to wonder what will happen when they realize that the campus buildings from which they lecture us for our failings are the product of the — gasp! — Western tradition of ­architecture.

 

 

 

The history of art reflects the history of the world. But erasing the past, its glories and its warts, only leaves people ignorant. You need to know about something to criticize it. Students won’t only fail to understand the evolution of art, they won’t appreciate other artistic traditions and customs, for they will have nothing to compare these to.

 

College professors suggest that dropping the introductory course is a response to student uneasiness, but since the course is more popular than ever, the queasiness likely came from the top. Those in charge of education have relinquished their ­responsibility to hand on to the young what they themselves ­received from the past.

 

But they should be careful what they wish for. In Poland, the new director of a major museum has complained that he is sick of left-wing dominance of the arts and plans to put his own agenda in place. As a conservative, patriotic, pro-family politician, his politics are different from those that reign at elite East Coast universities; but his justification for using the arts to advance “right-thinking” sounds similar. Once you openly politicize the arts, others will too.

 

Denying the influence of Western art means dismissing its great truth and beauty. Generations of people — black, brown and white, male and female, rich and poor — have found meaning and solace in the great Western tradition. This art will always lift the heart. The philistine faculty should fall. It is up to all of us who care about the best that has been thought and said to educate future generations — and show them why Western art deserves its place on the pedestal.

 

Tiffany Jenkins is author of “Keeping Their Marbles: How the Treasures of the Past Ended Up in Museums — And Why They Should Stay There.”

 

所有跟帖: 

对呀,几千年绘画历史,为什么要选毛主席这张? -fakegreen- 给 fakegreen 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 05:45:25

不光耶鲁,别的几所大学也在慢慢减少western canon,而增加多样化。也好也不好。如果有这方面的concern,应该 -糖甜甜- 给 糖甜甜 发送悄悄话 糖甜甜 的博客首页 (41 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 05:40:39

这个可以理解。但不理解的是为什么要选毛主席这张?中国绘画大师很多呀? -fakegreen- 给 fakegreen 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 05:47:07

毛主席去安源这幅画在中国艺术史上占有极其重要的地位 -糖甜甜- 给 糖甜甜 发送悄悄话 糖甜甜 的博客首页 (328 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 06:06:21

别的中国画有木有选进去?这张毛主席的比别的画都更有意义吗? -fakegreen- 给 fakegreen 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 06:22:36

喜欢你这个问题!当然有比如踏雪寻梅图 -糖甜甜- 给 糖甜甜 发送悄悄话 糖甜甜 的博客首页 (128 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 06:45:45

我怀疑编教材的有可能是我们这批新中国出生长大的 -fakegreen- 给 fakegreen 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 08:07:54

另外,如果有机会可以去纽约看看刚重新扩建装修的MOMA,比以前加了很多女性和minority艺术家作品 -糖甜甜- 给 糖甜甜 发送悄悄话 糖甜甜 的博客首页 (46 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 06:52:31

我曾经在一个小艺术馆看到过几幅画,刚看的时候还以为是早期印象派大师们的作品,结果发现是一个 -N.- 给 N. 发送悄悄话 N. 的博客首页 (328 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 08:16:23

软实力在提高, 无它! -牛老汉- 给 牛老汉 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 06:58:52

很喜欢安源的油画,把毛画的潇洒完美,尤其是那条红围巾。 -小团圆- 给 小团圆 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 12:34:50

因为“这是全世界复制最多的一幅画”,看把这幅画放在什么部分来讲 -花房姑娘- 给 花房姑娘 发送悄悄话 花房姑娘 的博客首页 (1009 bytes) () 01/28/2020 postreply 13:51:55

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!