about electric cars being a waste



Actually the point made several times about electric cars being a waste because the majority of electricity comes from coal is not true. One has to consider many concepts in chemistry, electrical and mechanical engineering to understand the real advantages of electric cars. The fundamental concept is that a relatively small internal combustion engine can never match the efficiency of a large, Rankine-cycle coal plant. Of course one must consider the efficiency losses in the transmission (significant for the internal combustion auto), losses in the motors for the electric vehicle (small), transmission line losses (small, electric vehicle) and losses in the fuel refining process, too, but I have done the calculations and electric keeps a strong lead. The other fundamental concept is "distributed pollution" versus "centralized pollution." Most people do not realize that coal-fired plants can be made to be extremely clean (low Sulfur, NOx, PM and heavy metals). While we have made great strides doing the same with internal combustion autos, it just doesn't make sense to invest in the type of equipment needed to remove these pollutants to the same degree.

Finally, there are viable sources of renewable energy on the market (MW scale wind) and on the horizon (MW scale solar thermal rankine and stirling cycle).

I hope this makes it clearer that electric IS superior to gasoline, even when coal is used as the plant fuel.

所有跟帖: 

恩,这个说的和我们这里的教授说的差不多。 -woth- 给 woth 发送悄悄话 woth 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 09:39:03

不过电动汽车的造价在现在来说确实算是比较高,不是很多人 -woth- 给 woth 发送悄悄话 woth 的博客首页 (86 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 09:42:48

奶奶哎,奶奶!!你是我奶奶,亲奶奶,咱说点别的吧!!! -杀雨- 给 杀雨 发送悄悄话 杀雨 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 09:49:19

哈哈哈。这位奶奶长得很俊俏地。哈哈 -用户名被占用了- 给 用户名被占用了 发送悄悄话 用户名被占用了 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 11:06:47

这个杀雨对woth可是有个大大的crush啊。 -白眼狼- 给 白眼狼 发送悄悄话 (44 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 11:15:44

she does not have a huby -yyang3- 给 yyang3 发送悄悄话 (95 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 13:46:16

she has a daughter too. -用户名被占用了- 给 用户名被占用了 发送悄悄话 用户名被占用了 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 14:15:13

回复:about electric cars being a waste -biglow- 给 biglow 发送悄悄话 biglow 的博客首页 (472 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 09:50:20

Show me the number -cys254- 给 cys254 发送悄悄话 (518 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 10:07:17

还不快搬? :-) -internuts- 给 internuts 发送悄悄话 internuts 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 12:44:42

如果光是煤电的话,数据要比我之前给出的高,我之前 -woth- 给 woth 发送悄悄话 woth 的博客首页 (544 bytes) () 04/03/2009 postreply 14:18:36

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!