美国高考錄取:考试公平与"阶级"公平的矛盾

 让我们继续上面的例子

(1) 2011年，哈佛录取7名  Northwest Suburban, Chicago, 读书好de学生
(two from two 5分 HS, one 8分; .....)

One form "Stevenson High School"

(2) 7名读书好de学生, GPA are 4.0, but, look at those ACT/SAT scores

Test scores: ACT: 33
Test scores: ACT: 34
Test scores: SAT: 2390
Test score: SAT: 2010
Test score: ACT: 35
Test score: ACT: 33
Test scores: ACT: 34; SAT: 2180
------------------

现在，我们可以理解下图

GPA vs. SAT Score ... 

http://features.thecrimson.com/2013/frosh-survey/admissions.html

------------------

如果哈佛录取学生像北大那样, all students would have GPA 4.0, and SAT very 
close to 2400/36.

把"Northwest Suburban, Chicago""作为一个例子, 北大, 按統一標準全州取士, 将招
收7名Stevenson High School ACT满分学生. (the "GPA vs. SAT Score" 图将完全不
同)

School: Stevenson High School Hometown: Buffalo Grove  (10分) 
[ 28 SEMIFINALISTS | 8  perfect ACT examination score ]

-------------------------
In the Class of 2017:

74% of schools sent only one student.

http://www.toptieradmissions.com/ivy-league-admissions/

------------------------
income

$500K+     14%
$250-500K  15%
$125-250K  24%
$80-125K   18%
$40-80K    15%
$40K-      15%

http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2013/9/4/freshman-survey-admissions-aid/

----------------------

------------------
The following ... most are selective HS:

The list of schools
Here's the list of schools that had five or more kids go to Harvard in the 
freshman class of 2008-9 / senior class of 2012.

20+ students
Boston Latin -- 23 students

10-20 students
Milton Academy -- 14 students (Milton, MA)
Phillips Exeter Academy -- 14 students (Exeter, NH)
Deerfield Academy -- 12 students (Deerfield, MA)
Stuyvesant -- 12 students (New York)
Phillips Academy (Andover) -- 10 students (Andover, MA)

5-9 students
Trinity School (New York) -- 8 students
Choate Rosemary Hall (Connecticut) -- 7 students
Collegiate School (New York) -- 7 students
The Roxbury Latin School (Roxbury, MA) -- 7 students
Belmont High School (Belmont, MA) -- 6 students
Groton School (Groton, MA) -- 6 students
Horace Mann School (New York) -- 6 students
Hunter College High School (New York) -- 6 students
Lexington High School (Lexington, MA) -- 6 students
Lowell High School (San Francisco, CA) -- 6 students
Winsor School (Boston, MA) -- 6 students
Greenwich High School (Greenwich, CT) -- 5 students
The Harker School (San Jose, CA) -- 5 students
Lakeside School (Seattle, WA) -- 5 students
Pine Crest School (Ft. Lauderdale, FL) -- 5 students
Troy High School (Fullerton, CA) -- 5 students
Weston High School (Weston, MA) -- 5 students
Mayfair High School (Lakewood CA)--9 students

---------------------

https://www.quora.com/Which-high-schools-did-the-Harvard-Class-of-2012-
attend

--------------------

: --------------

: alan2009, 你的观点, 什么是好学区 ? 
: ...................


alan2009, 这所高中是好HS，对不对？

21 semi-finalist ... only one 中国孩子, he goes to Brown
-------------

evanstonian     net/archived-in-depth/2015/05/29/where-do-we-go-now/

adc.   d211.   org/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/2015-Semifinalists-Natl-Merit-Program.pdf


Harvard College
Benedict 
Rachel 
Yale University
Emma 
Rachel 

Princeton University
Camilla 

Cornell University
Katie

Columbia University
Ben 

Brown University
Sam 
Liao
Graham 
Nate 
Aly 

Dartmouth Colle
Noah 

University of Pennsylvania
Natalie 

 

所有跟帖： 

• "学区房" 口耳相传这么多年 误导很多中国人. -bebe2014- ♂ (5908 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:31:11

• don't quite understand what you try to say, --worldance-- ♀ (255 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 10:27:10

• You will understand it after you read those on [Chicago] -bebe2014- ♂ (223 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 10:36:03

• 数据，只有数据告诉真相 -bebe2014- ♂ (9086 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:33:16

• 读书好的毕业生: national merit semifinalist 2015 -bebe2014- ♂ (5297 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:44:47

• 我们这里高中一年NMS 50几名，也是只有一个去哈弗 -backyardfun- ♀ (50 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:52:54

• 这个信息对中国人, 选择高中时, 有很大的帮助 -bebe2014- ♂ (367 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:58:53

• 有啥帮助，在哪里都一样的。 难道你头一次听说？ -keessa- ♀ (0 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 10:04:48

• 拿中西部举例不恰当。那个号称最好的stevenson一年也就不到百分之一上藤，都是小概率事件 -keessa- ♀ (68 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:34:38

• neighborhood high schools; exclude selective HS -bebe2014- ♂ (3157 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:37:15

• 你想说明啥？ 芝加哥就没有东西部那种超强的selective私高 -keessa- ♀ (0 bytes) () 07/20/2016 postreply 09:45:38