We need to see how many times the student took the SAT and perfect score is form a single test or supper score from multiple tests. If you only took one test and got 2350 but the other took five times and got 2400 super score, I would prefer the first one since 2350 and 2400 is not a very signifiant difference and admission officer will wonder if you have more important things to do than just taking SAT tests.