前几天the Atlantic首页重发了一篇老文WHY STUDY HISTORY

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1988/11/why-study-history/670027/

The plain fact is that American history is not intelligible, and we are not intelligible to ourselves, without a firm grasp of the life and ideas of the ancient world, of Judaism and Christianity, of Islam and Christendom in the Middle Ages, of feudalism, of the Renaissance and the Reformation, of the English Revolution and the Enlightenment. The first settlers did not sail into view out of a void, their minds as blank as the Atlantic Ocean. They were shaped and scarred by tens of centuries of religious, social, literary, and political experience. Their notions of honor and heroism were learned from Greco-Roman myth and history, from the Bible and the lives of the saints of the Church, from stories of knights and Crusaders, explorers and sea dogs of the Renaissance, soldiers and martyrs of the wars of religion. Those who sailed west to America came in fact not to build a New World but to bring to life in a new setting what they treasured most from the Old World

Studying history, said the Bradley Commission on History in Schools, helps students  to understand themselves and “otherness,” by learning how they resemble and how they differ from other people, over time and space; to question stereotypes of others, and of themselves; to discern the difference between fact and conjecture; to grasp the complexity of historical cause; to distrust the simple answer and the dismissive explanation; to respect particularity and avoid false analogy; to recognize the abuse of historical “lessons,” and to Weigh the possible consequences of such abuse; to consider that ignorance of the past may make us prisoners of it; to realize that not all problems have solutions; to be prepared for the irrational, the accidental, in human affairs; and to grasp the power of ideas and character in history.

英美同一个体系,跟欧洲大陆的思路有一些差别,但都很有意思。

十年前我迷上了美国开国史,就当传奇看。近几年迷上了英国史,从玫瑰战争,到Tudors, 到Stuarts, 跟我们的传统文化天差地别

 

 

 

所有跟帖: 

赞你一直爱读书! -两女宝妈- 给 两女宝妈 发送悄悄话 两女宝妈 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 12:49:50

牛啊 -zaocha2002- 给 zaocha2002 发送悄悄话 zaocha2002 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 12:58:50

读了几本美国独立战争和南北战争的书,对南北战争尤其感兴趣 -家有高中小娃- 给 家有高中小娃 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 13:07:03

Chernow前几年有本畅销书Grant, 很大部分就是写南北战争。他是历史学者,他的每一本既严谨又生动 -糯米粥- 给 糯米粥 发送悄悄话 糯米粥 的博客首页 (124 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 14:03:28

谢谢。 改天买一本 -家有高中小娃- 给 家有高中小娃 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 14:04:40

就是谁也打不过谁,都是学渣,诺曼、维京、罗马、盎撒;都留个心眼儿,王室、贵族、地主、厂商…就共和了。 -phobos- 给 phobos 发送悄悄话 phobos 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 13:37:00

谁也不想当孙子,于是就没有兵法一统天下。 -phobos- 给 phobos 发送悄悄话 phobos 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 13:38:00

亨八想过,歇菜了 -phobos- 给 phobos 发送悄悄话 phobos 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 13:39:00

争取最近回你。你的是宏观视角,我回的会是一些微观视角,原汁原味 -糯米粥- 给 糯米粥 发送悄悄话 糯米粥 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 13:59:29

以史为鉴,可以知兴替 -我是谁的谁- 给 我是谁的谁 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 13:52:48

就是不信邪。一代笨过一代。 -Bailey4321- 给 Bailey4321 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 06/03/2025 postreply 14:20:14

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!