A review of Service records indicates that the beneficiary's status was adjusted to that of a lawful permanent resident on September 28, 2005 (classification code:"E16"; priority dat: March 26, 2005; I-485: ref:SRC05 258 51444] (I added here, src 05 258 51444 is for the second I-140)
In the context of Section 203 (b) of the INA, a visa has already been allocated to the beneficiary in conjunction with his adjustment of status. As the beneficiary is already lawfully resident in the United States, the instant I-140 must be denied as it encompasses a benefit and an immigrant visa that already been accorded this beneficiary.
Best wishes