From cc :
I have been following this interesting thread for a while. It is good to know different opinions about the school my daughter is going to attend and the one she chose two years before graduating from HS. She was accepted in EA, and being one of the best students in her class (in the 3%, or less. Her school does not rank, but the top eight students were announced, her being among them), and after seeing the college acceptances of her group, I could tell that it is very likely that she could be accepted in any other school if she would have applied EA. However she did EA in Chicago (she was accepted in 7 schools (RD), Columbia, Cornell, UPenn, Duke, Vanderbilt, UMichigan and UVA). Why UChicago? I wrote a thread explaining that decision with detail, but in fewer words I can say that UChicago did a great job of making her feel like they REALLY wanted her: personal hand-written cards from the AO, merit scholarship, emails, etc, etc. On the other hand, the other important reason that was crucial for her decision was the location. She would not survive in a school located in the middle of nowhere. Having a city like Chicago as close as it is, is impossible to beat. The possibilities for internships, jobs, cultural life: concerts, museums, amazing restaurants, are all important aspects as well (at least for her). The widely criticized marketing has worked pretty well because every person I know that visited the university, after receiving cards, posters with spectacular pictures (me included), could not believe her eyes once there. UChicago was not properly known. That is why the school has had a "meteoric rise". Many people simply don't know the beauty of the architecture, the breathtaking campus, its amazing people (students, teachers, employees), the housing system (parallel to only Yale), convenient location, modern dorms and the academic rigor (she will do Econ and Poli Sci).
One of the best things about UChicago is that it has nothing to do with Harvard. UChicago is unique and I don't think that anybody there wants to emulate HPY. At least, I hope not.