你說得很對。

但普通人，其實包括學者應分好國家民族與個人。對個人來說，不要太在意這些。

關於印度，我曾說：

印度, 雖本非統一國家，却無疑拥有深厚的文化, 形散而神不散, 與形聚而神馳的俄羅斯恰好處於相反的状况. 但崛起之前它需要先找到自己的國家形式. 

 

Today's India is a framework resulted from western colonialism. It is an entity foreign to its own culture, a poor if not dysfunctional expression of its Will.  Hence India the state will need to transform itself, reinvent itself in order to make itself a proper apparatus for its culture. This is an extra phrase China never needed to go through. But given the depth and magnitude of India's culture and the intelligence and desire of the Indian people, there shouldn't be any doubt that this can be done though it may be a painstaking process and will take a perhaps much longer time. 

 

Once this is done, India is on its way to claim its proper place in this world as a major civilization.