谷狗是不是彻底舔共了?
不作翻译,不想跟不懂英文的人辩论。
"China does not recognize it under any circumstances" is a legal doctrine. It means that in the eyes of the Chinese government, your other citizenship is invisible and legally void. If you are a Chinese national, you cannot use your foreign passport to claim special rights (like foreign consular protection) while inside China. Here is how that works in practice and how it differs from a "requirement" to renounce.
1. The "Invisible" Passport
If you hold both a Chinese and a Canadian passport, and you enter China using Chinese travel documents:
? Legally: You are 100% a Chinese citizen.
? Consular Protection: If you get into legal trouble or are arrested, the Canadian embassy will not be allowed to visit you or provide legal aid. China will tell them, "This person is a Chinese national; your laws do not apply to them here."
2. Do you have to renounce to keep Chinese citizenship?
The law handles this in two very different ways depending on how you got your dual status:
A. If you voluntarily naturalized (e.g., you chose to become American)
? Automatic Loss (Article 9): You don't "have" to renounce. The law says you already lost your Chinese citizenship the moment you took the foreign oath.
? The Reality: Many people don't report this to the Chinese government and keep their Chinese ID (Hukou). However, if the government finds out (e.g., through fingerprinting at the border), they will cancel your Chinese status immediately. You don't have a choice to "keep" it.
B. If you were born with both (e.g., born in the US to Chinese parents)
? "Nationality Conflict": China views this not as "dual citizenship," but as a conflict of laws.
? The Solution: To keep your Chinese status as an adult, you typically do not have to show a certificate of renunciation for your foreign passport. Instead, China simply ignores your foreign passport. They will issue you a Chinese Travel Document (旅行证) instead of a regular passport to let you enter/exit.
? The Catch: Once you turn 18, if you want a regular Chinese Passport, you may be asked to formally renounce your foreign citizenship.
看看gemini怎么样解释谷的国籍
所有跟帖:
•
译文在此,实际就是这样。"不承认"和"不允许"不是同义词
-天青水蓝-
♂
(2138 bytes)
()
02/21/2026 postreply
10:37:18
•
桂民海事件说明中国政府对入籍外国的公民有司法权,这个由中国说了算。一日为中共草民,终身受威胁
-Dotline-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
02/21/2026 postreply
10:45:02
•
是啊,就像美国总统可以搞赦免一样。法律终究是工具。
-小米干饭-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
02/21/2026 postreply
10:50:58
•
桂民海的情况不同,他同时是香港永久居民,根据中国人大的解释,港澳华人不管持哪国护照都是中国公民,外国护照只视为旅行证件
-天青水蓝-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
02/21/2026 postreply
10:51:24
•
有香港居民证的人多了去,但中共国籍法也只敢管有中国血统的人,够歧视自卑吧
-Dotline-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
02/21/2026 postreply
11:01:06
•
看了你这么多帖子,感觉谷爱玲的身份没什么问题,悄咪咪过日子就行了。她这么出名这么高调,让很多拿不到双重身份的人很不爽。
-小米干饭-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
02/21/2026 postreply
10:49:22
•
中黑为啥稀罕双重国籍?越黑越爱国?
-小小得意楼-
♀
(0 bytes)
()
02/21/2026 postreply
11:50:38