不是的

 
 
 
No, a 
REAL ID driver's license is not sufficient on its own for ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) because it proves identity, not immigration status or citizenship; non-citizens are legally required to carry proof of lawful presence, like a passport, Permanent Resident Card, or work permit, as ICE can question and detain individuals based on status, and may not accept a REAL ID as definitive proof of citizenship, according to legal experts and news reports from early 2025/2026. 
Why a REAL ID Isn't Enough for ICE:
  • Identity vs. Status: A REAL ID confirms you are who you say you are, but not whether you're legally allowed to be in the U.S..
  • Not an Immigration Document: REAL IDs are for federal purposes like flying (TSA) or entering federal buildings, not for proving immigration status to immigration enforcement, note www.inforum.com and www.inforum.com.
  • Legal Requirement for Non-Citizens: The Immigration and Nationality Act requires non-citizens to carry documents proving their status, say www.inforum.com and www.inforum.com.
  • ICE Discretion: ICE officers can detain individuals and may not honor a REAL ID as proof of citizenship or lawful presence, even if it's issued by the state, according to news reports. 

所有跟帖: 

Real ID的保护确实是不够的,因为除了绿卡和公民,其他如学生/工作签证持有人,庇护申请人也都可以办理Real ID -天青水蓝- 给 天青水蓝 发送悄悄话 天青水蓝 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 10:33:57

Real ID只能证明你办理的那一刻还不算是完全的非法移民,之后学生可能因缺课被开除,工作签证因为失业变得无效,庇护被拒 -天青水蓝- 给 天青水蓝 发送悄悄话 天青水蓝 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 10:36:13

所以此人可能已经变成非法移民而可以被逮捕了,所以随身携带公民/移民文件还是必要的 -天青水蓝- 给 天青水蓝 发送悄悄话 天青水蓝 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 10:37:35

起码可以证明在办理realID 的时候在美国有合法居留权,不是非法进来的 -Uusequery- 给 Uusequery 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 10:37:54

现在DHS的解释是只要合法状态过期一天,哪怕已提交了绿卡申请I-485或庇护申请I-589,或H1B的延期只要还没批下来 -天青水蓝- 给 天青水蓝 发送悄悄话 天青水蓝 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 10:53:29

都是可以抓的,和合法入境或是非法入境无关。合法入境唯一的权利是可以向移民法官申请保释,非法入境连申请保释的权利都无 -天青水蓝- 给 天青水蓝 发送悄悄话 天青水蓝 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 10:55:08

圣地亚哥好几个和公民结婚的到移民局面谈时都被抓起来了,都合法入境绿卡申请提交后原非移民签证过期也抓,关几天后法官批准保释 -天青水蓝- 给 天青水蓝 发送悄悄话 天青水蓝 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 10:59:21

有个和公民结婚的乌克兰新娘,本来有移民局给的临时保护身份TPS,但因为递交了绿卡申请等面谈,就没去办TPS延期也给抓了。 -天青水蓝- 给 天青水蓝 发送悄悄话 天青水蓝 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 01/16/2026 postreply 11:07:05

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!