中国“鱼鹰”和美国鱼鹰的比较。

来源: 于 2025-08-21 09:24:52 [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：次
China is developing a tiltrotor aircraft, reportedly similar in size to the Leonardo AW609, which is considerably smaller than the U.S. V-22 Osprey. The Chinese prototype, unlike the V-22, appears to only rotate the rotors, not the entire engine nacelles. While the Chinese aircraft is smaller and likely has lower payload and range than the V-22, it may be more affordable and potentially simpler to develop. The V-22, on the other hand, is a battle-proven platform with a larger capacity, including a rear ramp, aerial refueling capability, and external cargo sling load transport. 
 
Key Differences:
  • Size and Weight:
    The Chinese tiltrotor is significantly smaller than the V-22, with a maximum gross weight around 18,000 pounds compared to the V-22's 52,000 pounds in VTOL mode. 
     
  • Engine/Rotor Configuration:
    The Chinese prototype appears to rotate only the rotors, while the V-22 rotates both the engines and rotors together. 
     
  • Payload and Range:
    The V-22 has a larger capacity for personnel and cargo, and its range is also greater than what is expected of the Chinese aircraft. 
     
  • Features:
    The V-22 has features like a rear ramp, aerial refueling capability, and external cargo sling load transport, which are not mentioned for the Chinese prototype. 
     
  • Maturity:
    The V-22 is a battle-proven platform with years of operational experience, while the Chinese tiltrotor is still in early testing stages. 
     
Potential Advantages of the Chinese Tiltrotor:
  • Simpler Design:
    The simpler design, with only the rotors rotating, may lead to a more affordable and potentially more reliable aircraft. 
     
  • Potential for Lower Cost:
    The smaller size and simpler design could translate to a lower development and production cost. 
     
Potential Advantages of the V-22:
  • Larger Capacity: The V-22 can carry significantly more personnel and cargo, making it suitable for a wider range of missions. 
     
  • Greater Range: The V-22's range allows for deployments over longer distances without refueling. 
     
  • Operational Maturity: The V-22 has a proven track record and established operational procedures.