如果州和联邦政府打官司,州还是可以要求nation wise injunction.

with this judge, can state file lawsuit against federal and ask for nationwide injunction?
 
Based on the recent Supreme Court ruling regarding nationwide injunctions, states 
may still be able to seek relief that could be akin to a nationwide injunction when suing the federal government, but the scope of such relief is currently uncertain. 
Here's why:
  • The Supreme Court explicitly left open the possibility that states might be granted nationwide relief in their lawsuits against the federal government, but it declined to definitively resolve the issue, deferring it to lower courts to consider.
  • Justice Amy Coney Barrett, in the majority opinion, indicated that a nationwide injunction might be necessary to provide "complete relief" to states in certain cases.
  • Lower courts will now have to determine whether a nationwide injunction is appropriate when a state brings a lawsuit against the federal government, and they will need to consider the arguments made by states about why such broad relief is needed. 
In summary:
The Supreme Court ruling limited the ability of individual judges to issue nationwide injunctions that block executive actions throughout the country. However, the court did not rule out the possibility that states could still obtain nationwide relief in their lawsuits against the federal government. The extent of that possibility and the circumstances under which such relief would be granted are now left to the lower courts to determine. 
 
AI responses may include mistakes. For legal advice, consult a professional. Learn more

所有跟帖: 

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!