一些中国人欢庆朝鲜战争胜利的一个潜在的假设:
54年朝鲜战争签订的是停战协议,不是终战协议。技术上讲,朝鲜战争还在继续,最后的胜利者还没有确定。很多中国人一直在宣称朝鲜战争的胜利。Google了一下朝鲜战争的伤亡情况:
Casualties
Korean War memorials are found in every UN Command Korean War participant country; this one is in Pretoria, South Africa.
According to the data from the U.S. Department of Defense, the United States suffered 33,686 battle deaths, along with 2,830 non-battle deaths during the Korean War and 8,176 missing in action.[255] South Korea reported some 373,599 civilian and 137,899 military deaths.[10] Western sources estimate the PVA suffered about 400,000 killed and 486,000 wounded, while the KPA suffered 215,000 killed and 303,000 wounded.[25]
Data from official Chinese sources, on the other hand, reported that the PVA had suffered 114,000 battle deaths, 34,000 non-battle deaths, 340,000 wounded, 7,600 missing and 21,400 captured during the war. Among those captured, about 14,000 defected to Taiwan while the other 7,110 were repatriated to China.[256] Chinese sources also reported that North Korea had suffered 290,000 casualties, 90,000 captured and a "large" number of civilian deaths.[256] In return, the Chinese and North Koreans estimated that about 390,000 soldiers from United States, 660,000 soldiers from South Korea and 29,000 other UN soldiers were "eliminated" from the battlefield.[256]
美军死亡(包括失踪)4万多人,美方估计中方战死40万人,中国官方数据为死亡(包括失踪15万多人。面对这样的数据,任何一个宣称给了美国人教训的人,都做了一个设定:中国人的命比美国人的命贱很多。我不做这样的设定,所以我不庆祝这样的胜利。
有人说朝鲜战争阻止了美国对中国的侵略,这是屁话。日本投降时,美国不想侵略中国;中国内战爆发时,美国不想侵略中国;李宗仁想划江而治时,美国不想侵略中国;蒋介石还有西南一隅时,美国不想侵略中国;到了中共占领了整个大陆,政权逐渐稳定时,美国就想侵略中国了。这些人的逻辑太狗屁,把美国人想得太笨。
应该说,中国士兵的表现值得钦佩。用美国人的话说就是:get job done. 但是一党之私,站到了错误的阵营,把中华民族引向劫难,应该受到谴责。