Bbc is crap. bbc version:China tightens death penalty law

China has approved a law allowing only the country's top court to approve death sentences, state media reports.
The move follows a series of miscarriages of justice since lower courts were given the right to approve the death sentence in the 1980s.

China's official state news agency, Xinhua, said it was believed to be the most important reform of capital punishment in more than two decades.

China is accused of carrying out more executions than any other country.

It will give the defendants in death sentence cases one more chance to have their opinions heard

Xiao Yang
China's chief justice

In 2005, it carried out an estimated 1,770 executions and sentenced nearly 4,000 people to death, human rights group Amnesty International says.

Small step

The change in the law, approved by the country's top legislature, is due to come into effect on 1 January 2007, Xinhua reported.

It means that all death penalty sentences given by lower courts must be reviewed and ratified by the Supreme Court.

CHINA'S DEATH PENALTY
China is believed to execute more people than rest of the world combined
Non-violent crimes such as tax fraud and embezzlement carry death penalty
Other crimes include murder, rape, robbery and drug offences
China does not publish official figures on executions
Many cases are based on confessions and trials often take less than a day, observers say

But it is unclear whether this will involve a full appeal hearing or, as it is at present in lower courts, simply a review of the paperwork from the initial trial.

Jerome Cohen, a US expert on the Chinese legal system, called the move a "step in the right direction", which shows the country's top judiciary is increasingly concerned by the death penalty system.

But he said more fundamental reform of the death penalty legislation is needed to change the way such cases are tried and appealed.

China's chief justice Xiao Yang called it "an important procedural step in preventing wrongful convictions".

"It will also give the defendants in death sentence cases one more chance to have their opinions heard," Mr Xiao said in comments carried by state media.

Miscarriages of justice

The Supreme Court had responsibility for reviewing all death penalty cases until the early 1980s when provincial courts were given the authority to issue the death sentence.

Early this year, death penalty cases began to be heard in public as China came under pressure at home and abroad over the rising number of miscarriages of justice.

Two cases of wrongful convictions got widespread coverage in the Chinese media last year.

A butcher executed for murder in 1989 was proved innocent when his alleged victim was found alive; while a man was freed after 11 years in jail when his wife, whom he was accused of killing, was also found alive.

The authorities are hoping the decision will tighten up the current process, but it remains to be seen whether it has any impact on the number of people being executed in China, the BBC's Dan Griffiths in Beijing says.

Capital punishment has a long history in China, and there is no indication the country is ready to give up the death penalty, our correspondent adds.

所有跟帖： 

• actual version:中国对死刑判决进行重大修改 -toploader- ♀ (4211 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:10:10

• they just want to demonize china. stupid media -toploader- ♀ (0 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:10:37

• Do you actually read English??? -●- ♂ (0 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:16:47

• don't do this, pls, show me your true oppinion! -toploader- ♀ (0 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:22:11

• "tightens death penalty law" -●- ♂ (83 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:27:47

• but it is not chinese, it is english. ask your colleague -toploader- ♀ (53 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:31:03

• the title above is CHINA TIGHTEN DEATH PENELTY LAW. -toploader- ♀ (262 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:26:40

• tighting up means gripping the death penalty sentences -kimJongIl- ♂ (155 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:30:13

• She has a messy logic. -●- ♂ (0 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:32:57

• thank you very much for you kind comments -toploader- ♀ (0 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:34:05

• 回复：i have to say -wxc610- ♀ (182 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:57:37

• in a common english mind, any tightened law from government -toploader- ♀ (101 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:33:32

• my friend, take it easy, it is a good news -KimJongIl- ♂ (106 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:25:17

• but the title is misleading!!! do you think any of common -toploader- ♀ (265 bytes) () 11/01/2006 postreply 05:29:36