同样的逻辑

来源: 2023-01-23 11:44:08 [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读:

THE RIGHTS OF SELT-PROTECTION.
Upon the point that the argument against the Chinese was an argument against all immigration, he contended that objections to the one instance were inapplicable as to European immigrants, who became producers and consumers, meet our laborers on an equality, and assimilate with us and become part of our Government. None of these things were true of the Chinese... Not only our naturalization laws, but the Burlingame Treaty contained express provision against their naturalization.

https://www.teachushistory.org/nineteenth-century-immigration/resources/millers-speech?

关于反对中国人的论点是反对所有移民的论点,他争辩说,"反对华人的逻辑不适用于欧洲移民,欧洲移民成为生产者和消费者,平等地与我们的劳动者会面,并与我们同化并成为 我们政府的一部分。 这些事情都不是中国人的真实情况……不仅是我们的入籍法,而且伯林格姆条约都包含禁止华人入籍的明确条款。“