pull out the history data that you can find protentional ...

If you can pull out the historical data that easy to compare.

Since the house for rent that you have to calculate protentional repair, tax, HOA fees, and etc.

The second one SFH 1300-1500 Sq that kind small. Is first one also SFH?  You should also list bathrooms. 

If you want a clear anser, you have to provide list link that can see the location and photos.