维基上还有一段对蒋的评价,我觉得很中肯,贴上来跟庞兄分享一下

来源: 阿留 2015-02-25 10:44:34 [] [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读: 次 (1761 bytes)
本文内容已被 [ 阿留 ] 在 2015-02-25 11:01:23 编辑过。如有问题,请报告版主或论坛管理删除.

“In recent years, there has been an attempt to find a more moderate interpretation of Chiang. Chiang is now increasingly perceived as a man simply overwhelmed by the events in China, having to fight simultaneously Communists, Japanese and provincial warlords while having to reconstruct and unify the country. His sincere, albeit often unsuccessful attempts to build a more powerful nation have been noted by scholars such as Jonathan Fenby and Rana Mitter. Mitter has observed that, ironically, today's China is closer to Chiang's vision than to Mao Zedong's. He argues that the Communists, since the 1980s, have essentially created the state envisioned by Chiang in the 1930s. Mitter concludes by writing that "one can imagine Chiang Kai-shek's ghost wandering round China today nodding in approval, while Mao's ghost follows behind him, moaning at the destruction of his vision".[97] Liang Shuming opined that Chiang Kai-shek's "greatest contribution was to make the CCP successful. If he had been a bit more trustworthy, if his character was somewhat better, the CCP would have been unable to beat him".[98]”


国人习惯于认为,既然一方被历史证明是错了,那当年他们的对手就是完全正确的。其实有时候双方都不尽如人意。。。如当年的国共两党,都是列宁式的专制政党,都有特务统治的味道,在大陆统治的时候都腐败(当然现在偶党是“青出于蓝”);同时期的德国,可能上台的一个是纳粹,一个是共产党,都是反历史潮流的。所以俺不赞成颂圣于任何一方。我们拖着千年的封建传统前行,故转型举步维艰。。。

所有跟帖: 

多谢阿留详尽的史料及分析,理科精英的方法论啊~~~ -庞士清- 给 庞士清 发送悄悄话 庞士清 的博客首页 (932 bytes) () 02/25/2015 postreply 15:50:32

揖谢庞兄赐教!“所谓现代文明建立于二战后的废墟和尸骨上”,"蒋比毛、国比共的文明基因稍多些",非常中肯透彻,双手赞同。 -阿留- 给 阿留 发送悄悄话 阿留 的博客首页 (1126 bytes) () 02/25/2015 postreply 16:25:02

深谢阿留细细回复,内见忧国忧民之心。另所言极是,对人民许诺天堂的,从来把人民带入地狱。。。 -庞士清- 给 庞士清 发送悄悄话 庞士清 的博客首页 (0 bytes) () 02/25/2015 postreply 18:13:32

加跟帖:

  • 标题:
  • 内容(可选项): [所见即所得|预览模式] [HTML源代码] [如何上传图片] [怎样发视频] [如何贴音乐]