Flawed question/answer?

来源: yma16 2003-11-06 08:16:00 [] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读: 次 (711 bytes)
本文内容已被 [ yma16 ] 在 2004-02-03 10:05:55 编辑过。如有问题,请报告版主或论坛管理删除.
一群人开舞会,每人头上都戴着一顶帽子。帽子只有黑白两种,黑的至少有一顶。每个人都能看到其他人帽子的颜色,却看不到自己的。主持人先让大家看看别人头上戴的是什么帽子,然后关灯,如果有人认为自己戴的是黑帽子,就打自己一个耳光。第一次关灯,没有声音。于是再开灯,大家再看一遍,关灯时仍然鸦雀无声。一直到第三次关灯,才有劈劈啪啪打耳光的声音响起。问有多少人戴着黑帽子?answer=3

I saw this question many times in different variations.
It seems that before the light is turned on second time, people who has black hat should slap their face.

For example, assume there are two people wearing the black hat. After the light is turn on and off once, there is no sound. This means everybody knows there must be more than one black hat. Then the two people wearing black hat should slap their face because they only saw one hat. Could you modify the question so that it makes sense?




所有跟帖: 

至少一顶 means more than or equal -野菜花- 给 野菜花 发送悄悄话 (4 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 10:22:00

I know that.What's your point? -yma16- 给 yma16 发送悄悄话 (63 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 10:50:00

回复:What's your point? -mathman123- 给 mathman123 发送悄悄话 (218 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 11:20:00

more explanation -yma16- 给 yma16 发送悄悄话 (670 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 13:03:00

I see your point, which makes -野菜花- 给 野菜花 发送悄悄话 (6 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 13:25:00

I don't see flaw -husonghu- 给 husonghu 发送悄悄话 (1363 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 22:03:00

打耳光改成举手 -杨利伟- 给 杨利伟 发送悄悄话 (0 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 17:05:00

Agree, What will happen if one -DXX1- 给 DXX1 发送悄悄话 (58 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 20:36:00

回复:Agree, What if there are -野菜花- 给 野菜花 发送悄悄话 (114 bytes) () 11/06/2003 postreply 21:01:00

请您先登陆,再发跟帖!

发现Adblock插件

如要继续浏览
请支持本站 请务必在本站关闭/移除任何Adblock

关闭Adblock后 请点击

请参考如何关闭Adblock/Adblock plus

安装Adblock plus用户请点击浏览器图标
选择“Disable on www.wenxuecity.com”

安装Adblock用户请点击图标
选择“don't run on pages on this domain”