向病人宣扬其独家草药可治癌症的加州医生Christine Daniel被判入狱14年

来源: 于 2013-11-16 05:47:37 [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：次

加州医生Christine Daniel，多年来向病人宣扬她的独家草药可以治愈癌症，导致多名患者延误治疗，包括一位本来治愈率极高的淋巴瘤患者耽误治疗而死亡。她经此敛财百万美元。DA在起诉状上写“她不但谋财而且害命”。检测发现她的药主要含浓缩牛肉精(beef extract)和防晒霜防腐剂(sunscreen preservative)。诉11项罪名成立，今年5月被判入狱14年。
无论何病，尤其是癌症，请接受根据循证医学(Evidence-based medicine)为基础的正规治疗。虽然现代医学尚未能攻克所有癌症，但是举个例，01年美FDA批准新药Gleevec（精准攻击 bcr-abl蛋白）后，98%的慢性粒细胞白血病患者显示完全缓解，该病的5年生存率从30%一跃升至89%，这就是现代医学的进步。Gleevec现在很贵，美国患者每月需付$2400---$3500左右，但好消息是这个专利明年就失效，其它药厂可以生产，届时每年大约只需$500了。

来源:  Christine Daniel: Doctor who claimed herbal concoction could cure ...

Doctor who claimed herbal concoction could cure cancer and duped $1m out of patients is jailed for 14 years

  • California doctor robbed patients of 'hopes and dreams of cure'
  • Herbal cure found to contain beef extract and sunscreen preservative

By Jessica Jerreat

PUBLISHED: 20:34 EST, 18 May 2013 | UPDATED: 06:07 EST, 19 May 2013

A California doctor who duped patients out of more than $1 million after claiming her herbal supplements could cure cancer has been jailed for 14 years.

Christine Daniel charged patients up to $100,000 for six months of treatment, which she claimed could also cure diabetes and multiple sclerosis.

'Daniel robbed victims of more than money – she also stole their hopes and dreams for a cure,' U.S. Attorney Andre Birotte Jr. said after the doctor was sentenced.

 
Fraud: Dr Christine Daniel has been jailed after conning patients out of money for her herbal cancer cure

Fraud: Dr Christine Daniel has been jailed after conning patients out of money for her herbal cancer cure

The 58-year-old was also ordered to pay back nearly $1.3 million, by U.S. District Judge Robert Timlin, who sentenced her over four counts of mail and wire fraud, six counts of tax evasion and one count of witness tampering.

The doctor and Pentecostal minister claimed her natural cancer treatment had a 60 to 80 per cent chance of success for advanced stages of the disease.

Claims that the supplements were natural and blended specifically for individual patients were found to be false in court.

It actually contained sunscreen preservative, beef extract flavoring and other ingredients that would not have any effect on cancer or other diseases, expert testimony proved.

Some of the Los Angeles doctor's patients died from complications after taking her supplement, including Paula Middlebrooks, who was charged nearly $60,000, the court was told.

After five months Daniel claimed Ms Middlebrooks was free of cancer, and threw her a party. However, the Georgia woman's breast cancer had spread and she died soon after.

Debra Harris, whose sister Barbara died after being treated by Daniel, submitted a letter to the court saying: 'I live with the guilt that I should have seen that none of what she was going through was helping her, but instead was hurting her.'

It wasn't only Daniel's patients who were convinced they could be cured, Ms Harris said. Their families  'wanted to believe it just as bad,' The Washington Post reported.

Another case highlighted during the trial was that of a 22-year-old woman who was suffering from neck lymphoma.

Although her condition could be cured, the woman died because Daniel recommended that she should avoid having radiation or chemotherapy.

 
Callous: From her Los Angeles clinic Daniel would prescribe her supplement and advise against chemotherapy

Callous: From her Los Angeles clinic Daniel would prescribe her supplement and advise against chemotherapy

'Daniel is responsible for a shockingly cold-hearted fraud that has brought her a richly deserved federal prison sentence,' Mr Birotte said in a statement published by the Huffington Post.

The court heard from 28 former patients and family members of cancer sufferers who had died.

Some told the court they were advised to avoid chemotherapy and to not take pain killers while being treated by Daniel.

This led to some spending the last few months of their lives in agony, Cal Coast News reported.

Daniel was also accused of trying to influence at least two witnesses at her trial, including a former patient.

And, in an attempt to make her clinic, which operated under names including Sonrise Wellness Center, appear as a non-profit organization, Daniel told patients to classify medical service payments as donations.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Joseph Johns said in court documents that Daniels had 'a merciless and callous indifference to the suffering of her patients and their family members'.

He added: 'It is unlikely that our federal criminal justice system will see the like of defendant Christine Daniel again.'